| Career Rushing | Years | Att. | Yards | TD |
| 1. Will Castleberry | 1997-2000 | 944 | 4,546 | 45 |
| 2. Ryan Reynolds | 1991-94 | 669 | 3,666 | 31 |
| 3. Cordario Collier | 2006-09 | 635 | 3149 | 43 |
| 4. Derrick Jett | 1991-93 | 563 | 2,686 | 37 |
| 5. Tyran Thompson | 2002-05 | 544 | 2,631 | 24 |
| 6. Dan Calhoun | 1992-96 | 493 | 2,386 | 24 |
| 7. Carlton Carter | 1992-95 | 448 | 2,289 | 31 |
| 8. Curtis Williams | 1998-99, 01 | 419 | 2,218 | 22 |
| 9. Domonique Hayden | 2010-present | 362 | 2,006 | 32 |
| 10. Kendall Owens | 2008-11 | 281 | 1,850 | 16 |
| Career Passing | Years | Att-Comp-Int | Yards | TD |
| 1. Dustin Hicks | 1995-98 | 858-442-36 | 5,745 | 35 |
| 2. Trevor Stellman | 2005-06, 08-09 | 672-399-24 | 5,328 | 50 |
| 3. Jesse Lowrey | 1999-01 | 647-304-13 | 4,357 | 38 |
| 4. Larry Hutson | 1992-95 | 620-346-22 | 4,042 | 40 |
| 5. John Paul Case | 1990-93 | 620-326-19 | 3,757 | 32 |
| 6. Rob Kues | 2009-11 | 500-293-10 | 3,664 | 34 |
| 7. Nate Berkley | 2002-05 | 470-230-32 | 3,625 | 31 |
| 9. Seth Ellis | 2003-05 | 215-130-13 | 1,687 | 13 |
| 10. Scott Garver | 2000-02 | 264-129-18 | 1,607 | 18 |
| Career Receptions | Years | Receptions/Yds | Avg. | TD |
| 1. Todd Naumann | 1991-94 | 108-1,748 | 16.2 | 14 |
| 2. Craig Rieck | 1996-99 | 65-1,501 | 23.1 | 15 |
| 3. Kendall Owens | 2008-11 | 118-1,447 | 12.3 | 10 |
| 4. Chase Weber | 2003-06 | 67-1,296 | 17.9 | 18 |
5. Andy Shields |
1996-98 |
98-1,262 |
12.9 |
2 |
6. Nick Dew |
2005-08 |
106-1,247 |
11.7 |
12 |
7. Chris Kent |
1994-97 |
86-1,201 |
14.0 |
9 |
| 8. Cordario Collier | 2005-09 | 100-1,132 | 11.2 | 7 |
9. John Resch |
2004-07 |
74-976 |
13.2 |
8 |
10. Jeff Krohmer |
1997-99 |
60-973 |
16.2 |
6 |
Career Tackles |
Years |
TCKL |
| 1. Mark Carlisle | 2003-06 | 445 |
| Mike Wolf | 1991-93 | 445 |
| 3. Chris Wells | 1993-95 | 413 |
| 4. Chris A. Wells | 1996-98 | 360 |
| 5. Brad Steinmetz | 2005-06, 08-09 | 326 |
| 6. Nick Gramke | 2009-present | 268 |
| 7. Nick Rice | 1999-02 | 264.5 |
| 8. Brandon Kohrs | 2006-09 | 257 |
| 9. Quincy Vinson | 1996-98 | 256 |
| 10. Eric Fette | 1998-01 | 236 |
| Career Scoring | Years | Points | ||
| 1. Will Castleberry | 1997-00 | 296 | ||
| 2. Cordario Collier | 2006-09 | 270 | ||
| 3. Derrick Jett | 1991-94 | 222 | ||
| 4. Domonique Hayden | 2010-present | 216 | ||
| 5. Dustin Zink | 2007-10 | 214 | ||
| 6. Ryan Reynolds | 1991-94 | 210 | ||
| 7. Kendall Owens | 2008-11 | 200 | ||
| 8. Carlton Carter | 1992-95 | 198 | ||
| 9. Erik Ward | 1993-95 | 160 | ||
| 10. Curtis Williams | 1998-99, 01 | 152 | ||
Single Season Rushing |
Year |
Yards |
||
| 1. Will Castleberry | 2000 |
1,736 |
||
| 2. Ryan Reynolds | 1994 |
1,280 |
||
| 3. Domonique Hayden | 2010 | 1,195 | ||
| 4. Will Castleberry | 1997 |
1,184 |
||
| 5. Ryan Reynolds | 1992 |
1,171 |
Game: 321, Will Castleberry at Bluffton, 1997
Single Season Passing |
Year |
Att-Comp-Int |
Yards |
TD |
| 1. Dustin Hicks | 1998 |
293-155-12 |
2,203 |
20 |
| 2. Trevor Stellman | 2009 |
228-141-9 |
2,032 |
26 |
| 3. Rob Kues | 2010 |
255-149-7 |
1,893 | 16 |
| 3. Larry Hutson | 1995 |
241-135-3 |
1,885 |
13 |
| 4. Trevor Stellman | 2008 |
242-148-6 |
1,856 |
11 |
| 5. Dustin Hicks | 1997 |
287-144-14 |
1,800 |
7 |
Game: 385, Nate Berkley vs Muskingum, 2003
Single Season Receiving |
Year |
Rec. |
Yards |
TD |
| 1. Craig Rieck | 1998 |
37 |
988 |
11 |
| 2. Andy Shields | 1998 |
55 |
697 |
1 |
| 3. Todd Naumann | 1994 |
37 |
649 |
6 |
| 4. Chase Weber | 2006 |
35 |
628 |
7 |
| 5. Nick Dew | 2008 |
50 |
583 |
7 |
Game: 193, Jeff Krohmer at Alma, 1998
| Single Season Tackles | Year |
Tackles |
| 1. Mike Wolf | 1992 |
167 |
| 2. Chris R. Wells | 1995 |
155 |
| 3. Mark Carlisle | 2005 |
147 |
| 4. Chris R. Wells | 1993 |
145 |
| 5. Mike Wolf | 1993 |
136 |
Game: 25, Dave Burke vs. Earlham College, October 6, 1990
** Updated Nov. 22, 2011
