| Date | Location | Result | |
| 05/08/09 | Washington, Pa. | Grove City 10, Thomas More 9 | Box score |
| 05/07/09 | Washington, Pa. | Thiel 11, Thomas More 5 | Box score |
| 05/03/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 4, Westminster 3 | Box score |
| 05/02/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 8, Westminster 1 | Box score |
| 05/02/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 11, Westminster 3 | Box score |
| 04/27/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 10, Miami-Middletown 1 | Box score |
| 04/25/09 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 15, Thomas More 1 | Box score |
| 04/25/09 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Waynesburg 9, Thomas More 3 | Box score |
| 04/24/09 | Waynesburg, Pa. | Thomas More 19, Waynesburg 13 | Box score |
| 04/23/09 | Washington, Pa. | Wash. & Jefferson 11, Thomas More 10 | Box score |
| 04/18/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 12, Grove City 3 | Box score |
| 04/18/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Grove City 6, Thomas More 4 | Box score |
| 04/17/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 8, Grove City 5 | Box score |
| 04/16/09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton 12, Thomas More 7 | Box score |
| 04/15/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 6, Wash. & Jefferson 5 | Box score |
| 04/15/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Wash. & Jefferson 6, Thomas More 1 | Box score |
| 04/11/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 7, Bethany 2 | Box score |
| 04/11/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 4, Bethany 0 | Box score |
| 04/11/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 8, Bethany 2 | Box score |
| 04/09/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 16, Capital 13 | Box score |
| 04/08/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 11, Centre 10 | Box score |
| 04/05/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Thomas More 19, Thiel 12 | Box score |
| 04/04/09 | Greenville, PA | Thiel 6, Thomas More 3 | Box score |
| 04/04/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Thomas More 10, Thiel 0 | Box score |
| 04/01/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 6, Transylvania 3 | Box score |
| 03/31/09 | Springfield, Ohio | Wittenberg 14, Thomas More 8 | Box score |
| 03/28/09 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Thomas More 7, Geneva 6 | Box score |
| 03/27/09 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Thomas More 2, Geneva 1 | Box score |
| 03/27/09 | Beaver Falls, Pa. | Geneva 10, Thomas More 6 | Box score |
| 03/24/09 | Delaware, Ohio | Thomas More 5, Ohio Wesleyan 1 | Box score |
| 03/22/09 | Latrobe, Pa. | Thomas More 13, Saint Vincent 4 | Box score |
| 03/21/09 | Latrobe, Pa. | Thomas More 13, Saint Vincent 0 | Box score |
| 03/21/09 | Latrobe, Pa. | Thomas More 9, Saint Vincent 5 | Box score |
| 03/18/09 | Danville, Ky. | Thomas More 12, Centre 7 | Box score |
| 03/17/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 8, Hanover 7 | Box score |
| 03/13/09 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Thomas More 11, New Jersey City 6 | Box score |
| 03/12/09 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Thomas More 16, Baldwin-Wallace 9 | Box score |
| 03/11/09 | Winter Haven, Fla. | Thomas More 9, Albion 8 | Box score |
| 03/10/09 | Auberndale, Fla. | Thomas More 17, St. Joseph's (Maine) 7 | Box score |
| 03/09/09 | Auberndale, Fla. | Cortland State 4, Thomas More 3 | Box score |
| 03/03/09 | Hanover, Ind. | Thomas More 7, Hanover 7 | Box score |